Composting Toilet Vs Septic Tank(Off Grid Toilet System)2023

composting toilet vs septic tank

While toilets, septic systems and composting toilets aren’t maintenance-free. They require more effort to keep them functioning. The chances of needing to pump a composting toilet tank depend on how often you use it and how big it is. In contrast, a septic tank needs to be pumped once every three to five years, while a composting toilet tank may need to be emptied several times per month.

A composting toilet eliminates the need for a separate septic tank while allowing human waste to be managed in a healthy sanitary manner. Additionally, composting toilets have the potential to prevent contamination of groundwater and surface water sources that septic tanks and sewer systems commonly cause

Composting Toilet vs Septic

You can save money and the environment by installing a composting toilet or septic system. There can be a huge amount of money spent on laying a sewage line. This process often leads to a lot of water being wasted. The maintenance requirements for a composting toilet will be minimal or nonexistent if it is constructed and operated properly. The weather or other causes may cause damage to it, so you should inspect it once a month to be on the safe side. A tight seal should be observed on the rear wall covers.

What is Composite Toilet

Biologically, composting toilets treat human waste by decomposing it. The process results in the decomposition of organic matter and creates composted material from human waste. Human waste can be safely disposed of using a composting toilet which minimizes water usage. Using a combination of sawdust, peat moss or coconut coir combined with an anaerobic processing system, the toilet eliminates odors through an anaerobic system. Let’s understand the composite toilet with its feature given below:

The space available

Compact composting toilets with small waste tanks are ideal for tiny homes and boats. Rather than having an additional holding tank, composting toilets take up more floor space. You might be able to get the increased holding capacity by installing a split-system if space allows. In a garage or a cabin, you may be able to add a hopper. If you live in a warmer climate, you might be able to install your tank outside.


Portability is the most important feature that needs to be discussed in detail. The composted humanure can be used to strengthen a lawn or garden after it has been composted. Plants and soil are nourished by the byproducts of composting. Human waste is decomposed by bacteria in composting toilets. As the bacteria feed on organic compounds in liquid and solid waste, they separate them for bacterial activity.

Nothing of the sort is accomplished by a portable toilet. All waste from portable toilets goes into one waste tank without being separated into liquids and solids. The end product must still be channeled into a sewer or septic system after enzymes and deodorizer are poured into the tank to break down solids. For permanent residences such as mobile homes and tiny houses, portable toilets may not be the best choice.

Amount of storage in the tank

Whether or not you need a large tank depends on the number of people who will be using your composting toilet. The manufacturer usually breaks this down based on the size of the family and how it will be used.

The self-contained composting toilet with a five-gallon tank is more than sufficient for one adult whereas a split system with a large tank can handle waste from three adults or a family of five. A correctly sized tank will give waste enough time to decompose and become manure before it is filled.

The use of utilities

There is a lot of oxygen in the air for the aerobic bacteria to feed on as they break down the waste. The air is drawn across the waste by a fan powered by electricity in some composting toilets. Furthermore, the bacteria release carbon dioxide into the air by exchanging it with oxygen. There are many that can be used with the 110V system in a home but others can also be used with a 12V DC battery from a car or RV.

Water lines may also be required for composting toilets. Despite the fact that composting toilets use little water with each flush, they consume far less than standard toilets. The best toilet depends on the household budget and utility setup. Waterless and non-electric models are also available.

Elimination of odors

A lack of oxygen may cause bacteria to produce bad odors or impede their performance. A composting toilet must vent the gasses created by its bacteria. It also removes unpleasant odors by forcing gasses out through the vent used by some models to draw air into the tank. When decaying solids, coconut husks, sawdust, and other organic materials are added to the waste after each use, the bacteria are able to break down the waste without releasing any odors.

Related Articles: American Vs European Toilets

What is Septic Tank

For basic sewage treatment, domestic wastewater flows through a septic tank which is a concrete, fiberglass or plastic chamber underground. Despite reductions in solids and organics, anaerobic digestion and setting methods are not very efficient. The septic tank is a buried, water-tight container usually made of concrete, fiberglass, or polyethylene. As part of your subsurface disposal system, you first have to treat sewage in your septic tank. It would prevent the purifying processes of leaching and soil percolation if the sewage were not treated.

Every three to five years, septic tanks in homes are pumped. A mechanical or electrical alternative system should be inspected more often, generally once a year, if it uses float switches, pumps, or mechanical components. Solid waste can accumulate in your septic tank and move into the drainfield if the sludge becomes too thick. The drainfield will no longer function properly if these pipes become clogged with solid waste. If water flows through the pipes in the field instead of through the pipes properly, a pool can form.


It is possible to choose from a variety of septic tanks of different sizes. In order to determine the size of the tank that is right for your family, you must determine how much water they use on a daily basis. Septic tanks with capacities of 900 gallons or more are required if you use less than 500 gallons of water per day. A tank with a capacity of at least 1,200 gallons should be considered by families who use between 500 and 700 gallons of water per month. Depending on the local bylaws, some residences may be required to have a certain size of tank.


There are many different designs of septic tanks but their basic principles are the same. A pressure-type septic system is recommended when your tank will be installed in an area where gravel or coarse soil is present. Gravity systems are best suited to soils and dirt that are rich. The type of septic system you can have may also be governed by the location as with the size.


Septic tanks need to be operated and maintained properly. A system whose life expectancy is shortened by neglect or misuse will be less effective in the long run. Don’t use garbage disposal too often. In this way, your system can accumulate twice as much solids. Showers, car washing, and laundry use up a lot of water. Try to space out these activities. Each load of laundry can waste as much as 200 liters of water.

The valves and faucets should be repaired if they are leaking. Approximately 10,000 liters of water are wasted by a tap leaking one drop per second. There can be 20 times as much waste from a silent leaking toilet. We’re fortunate to live in a time when preserving water is easy. Use the plug and water in the sink for anything from washing vegetables to washing dishes to brushing your teeth and shaving.


There are two types of pumps that can be used in septic systems regardless of their size or design. Since turbine pumps tend to last longer and are more reliable, they are considered the superior of the two. The increased reliability of these systems often results in a higher price. In spite of the fact that centrifugal pumps tend to be less expensive, they may not last as long. It is easy to choose the right pump for your tank since both turbine and centrifugal pumps come in different sizes.

When choosing a new septic system, there are many factors to consider. You should always consult a contractor if you’re unsure of your home’s pump, design, or tank size. There are various brands and types of septic systems available and septic contractors have in-depth knowledge of them. As well as providing you with a better understanding of the project scope, they can also assist you with the installation process.

Worth Reading: Delta Vs Kohler Toilet


Just refresh your mind with the worthy information on the most demanding topic “Composting Toilet vs Septic Tank”. By far, the composting toilet is your best option if you want to be super eco-friendly. While it requires more maintenance, you save on water while feeding the ecosystem around you with natural fertilizer. Aside from being cheaper, it also offers more functionality. It is less eco-friendly to use a septic container in rural areas. Nonetheless, it will reduce water consumption and is better than landfills in terms of water conservation. Providing the toilet systems are maintained, hygiene shouldn’t be an issue. Asap Septic Tanks offers a variety of septic tanks.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *